1. Scholastics seems to deal with the correlation of ideas. The main goal of Scholasticism seems to me to be making everything fit without contradictions. As we read in the Wikipedia article, disagreements about texts were laid out and broken down until the two arguments were made into agreements. If we stayed in the scholastic period we would not have the science based on empirical evidence that we have today. Scholasticism trys to correlate too many ideas to the bible, when not all ideas can necessarily correlate with it. What happens is everything is broken down into meaningless non-sense that is debated upon for days by the scholars until an agreement is made. If Scholastics will still a major form of thought, progress would be non-existent, and in it's place we would have stagnation.
2. Scholastics saw faith and reason to be two sides of the same coin. Scholastics like Aquinas believed that reason was a divine gift that allows us to understand the world around us and see truth. He called in natural revlation, but Aquinas says this is one side to understanding the the truth of the world. The other side is faith which allows us to see beyond what is in front of us in the physical world and transcend into the relm of pure truth. It seems that the Scholastics believed faith to be the objective truth while reason to be a lesser form of truth that is more subjective. It seems to be remisent of plato's idea of the forms in that there are two ideas of reality, the one we have to reason and the one we transcend to attain pure truth.
3. The Church seemed to not adhere to a strict rule of what consents dissent. It seems with the case of Tommaso Capanella his rejection of Aristotelian lead to his estrange meant with the Church and his temperament with offensive views lead to his imprisonment by the Church. While still believed in the word god his views of faith were different. The same problems arose with Giordano Bruno, his ideas of faith were not congruent with church doctrine. Galileo also caused uproar with his ideas, but it wasn't just the ideas them selves, it was the way in which he presented them to society. He would attack anyone who raised opposetion to his views with searing pen strokes. Galileos ideas though went against common belief and his attitude to those who raised opposetion caused him to not have alot of friends inside the church. Church seemed to question philosophical and common belief dissent during the Scholastic period, but what really links these three philosophers was their attitudes towards the church at the time.
4. Universals are the abstract idea of objects, I.E. John, Steve, and Hamid are all humans. Humanity is the universal that ties the tree together. The problems of universals deals with there status, whether they exist independently from the object or if they are just a convenient way of correlating objects together. There are two schools of thought that go into the problem of universals, first is realism meaning that universals are real and they exist outside of the context of the object. Second is nominalism is the correlating of objects stating that universals don't exist. Scholastics thought that the world was made up of universals, that god had a independent set of cateogories that each object or concept falls into. The modern thought on the concept of univerals seemed to come to frutiation at the end of scholastism with Ockham's razor, which by shaving off the compliacted thoughts of reasoning of realism favors nominalism.
Monday, January 19, 2009
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
